The Great Charlotte Bronte Debate

This was huge fun: on June 11th at 7.30pm I took part in a debate in Haworth run by the Bronte Parsonage Museum to ‘decide’ which was Charlotte Bronte’s best novel. For a passionately argued and often funny hour and a half, Lucy Hallett-Hughes and myself defended ‘Villette’ while Joanne Harris and Claire Harman defended ‘Jane Eyre’. Tracy Chevalier chaired the debate and the actor Maxine Peake read wonderfully from the books. Votes were cast before and after the debate, and though ‘Jane Eyre’ remained the outright winner, we of the ‘Villette’ team were delighted with a significant swing to our side!

“Lucy Hughes-Hallett; Katherine Langrish; Maxine Peake; Tracy Chevalier; Joanne Harris and Claire Harman. A fantastic line-up of entertaining and articulate women debating the novels of Charlotte Brontë. Certainly a night to remember!” The Bronte Parsonage Museum.